伊犁银路工程建设有限责任公司精河县温商房地产开发有限责任公司建设工程施工合同纠纷民事二审民事判决书

Ђ

ñ ʂ Ő ʩ

2021153

ɏ˟ȋ2-202Ɍƌ

ί͐˟ˏ

ί͐˟ˏ

ɏ˟ȋ

ί͐˟ˏ

ί͐˟ˏ

ԭɳ1964Ī3Ԃ17ȕ

ԭɳ1991Ī7Ԃ18ȕ

ԭɳ1966Ī6Ԃ29ȕ

ԭɳ1987Ī8Ԃ11ȕ

ɏ˟ȋҁ'Ҹ·Ҕς201927ñ392021Ī5Ԃ12ȕb2021Ī6Ԃ16ȕͥ

Ҹ·1.2.19,713,648.54Ԫ3.4,693,080.46Ԫ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕưց2019Ī8Ԃ19ȕֹ4.8752019Ī8Ԃ20ȕ֮19,713,648.54ԪΪ4.650,000Ԫ5.һ6#9#12#14#Ɍס¥17#20#23#26#27#28#29#¥2013Ī6Ԃ˾÷ȷɪǫ3,804,176.07Ԫ20041461,700.4Ԫ202,280.13Ԫ1,506,479.38Ԫ201419άΡ311,423.68Ԫ321,159.07Ԫɳ604,130.38Ԫ18#21#22#24#25#7#8#10#11#¥12992,386.44ԪӦ7#8#10#11#18#21#22#24#25#¥һ76,777,922.05Ԫ131,122,583.68Ԫ19,720,978.56Ԫ11,401,605.12Ԫ216,219,773.63Ԫ320,886,154.22Ԫ286,392Ԫ3,789,688.34Ԫ27,927,685.22Ԫ4,824,173.05Ԫ֐ȷȏ1,241,413.05Ԫ3,582,759ԪҔ41,848,545.83Ԫ69,756,316.58Ԫ7,934,774.04Ԫ7,934,774.04Ԫ2,897,820Ԫ3,532,760Ԫ2,897,820Ԫ3,532,760Ԫ

΂Ɍսȷ

͵ș

΂Ɍ11,174,492.07Ԫ21,174,492.07Ԫ3%931,198.94Ԫ˄3%323,330.18Ԫ1,174,242.72Ԫ1556,141.41ԪӦӨ·2171,830.64ԪӦӨ6#9#12#14#17#20#23#26#27#28#29#¥75,350.43Ԫ93,345.64Ԫ3,134.57Ԫ3110,406.27ԪӦӨ120Ԫ/×1,220Ԫ/ƽ4335,864.4ԪӦӨ20#¥һ302ʒϖδƌɨ2020Ī9Ԃ14ȕ555,131ԪӦӨ1.23#26#27#28#¥ɨ͢ǽ80ϮĿ251,306.82Ԫ2.6#9#12#14#17#23#¥֐y˜25,792.96Ԫ3100,756Ԫ428,740.4Ԫ5.9#20#26#29#¥60%һ2013Ī750Ԫ/b2,000Ԫ/bʮ̵Լ2011107,945.2Ԫ624,255.22Ԫ7.6#9#12#14#¥֐ɢˮς300mm16,334.4Ԫ852,167.69Ԫ1125,000Ԫ50,000Ԫ70,000Ԫ5,000Ԫʕ̵֘2484,410.35Ԫ484,410.35Ԫ3155,905.35ԪӦ4141,851.99Ԫ3,836,070.53Ԫ2,661,578.46Ԫ1,174,492.07Ԫ

Ҹ·3%ûӐʂʵ3%3%323,330.18Ԫ1,174,242.72Ԫ171,830.64Ԫ110,406.27Ԫ335,864.4Ԫ555,131Ԫϻ70,000Ԫ484,410.35Ԫ141,851.99Ԫ70,000Ԫʇ͵ң

͵ș

Ҹ·ϲһɳ118,000,000Ԫ24,563,000Ԫ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց2019Ī12Ԃ13ȕ18,000,000Ԫ2019Ī12Ԃ14ȕư318,000,000Ԫ

΂Ɍ12,226,211.72Ԫ27,934,774.04Ԫ

һɳ2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ16#9#12#14#Ɍס¥232012Ī9Ԃ29ȕǰ2012Ī11Ԃ10ȕ2013Ī5Ԃ10ȕǰͪ2013Ī6Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2013Ī8Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2013Ī9Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2010Īה֎ǸרӃ2011Ī2012Ī6Ԃ6#¥3811.1ƽ1,220Ԫ4,649,542Ԫ9#¥3835.33ƽ1,220Ԫ4,679,102Ԫ12#¥4041.48ƽ1,220Ԫ4,930,605Ԫ14#¥3996.25ƽ1,220Ԫ4,875,425Ԫ19,134,674Ԫʶͼֽ2.2×2.2×Բ2013Ī6Ԃ22Ϯ9Ϯ

2012Ī11Ԃ4ȕɌסСǸ6#9#12#14#2012Ī11Ԃ5ȕ6#9#12#14#16932.15ʱ2012Ī11Ԃ5ȕ2013Ī9Ԃ11ȕ310̬14,306,033.83Ԫ2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ˹ǩ15%25%35%50%70%80%90%5%׷Ϊ14̬Ě2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ˹ǩ

2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ117#20#23#26#27#28#29#232012Ī9Ԃ29ȕǰ2012Ī11Ԃ10ȕ2013Ī5Ԃ10ȕǰͪ2013Ī6Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2013Ī8Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2013Ī9Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2010Īה֎ǸרӃ2011Ī2012Ī6Ԃ17#¥3943.68ƽ1,220Ԫ4,811,289Ԫ20#¥3835.33ƽ1,220Ԫ4,679,102Ԫ23#¥4041.48ƽ1,220Ԫ4,930,605Ԫ26#¥3815.79ƽ1,220Ԫ4,655,263Ԫ27#¥3788.55ƽ1,220Ԫ4,622,031Ԫ28#¥2512.15ƽ1,220Ԫ3,064,823Ԫ29#¥2644.61ƽ1,220Ԫ3,226,421Ԫ619.95ƽ1,220Ԫ756,339Ԫ30,745,876Ԫ2.2×2.2×Բ2013Ī6Ԃ22Ϯ9Ϯ

2012Ī11Ԃ4ȕɌסСǸ17#20#23#26#27#28#29#2012Ī11Ԃ5ȕ17#20#23#26#27#28#29#ȝ27067.882012Ī11Ԃ5ȕ2013Ī9Ԃ11ȕ310̬22,794,246.07Ԫ2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ˹ǩ15%25%35%50%70%80%90%5%׷Ϊ14̬Ě2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ˹ǩ

2013Ī9Ԃ10ȕϮĿ7#8#10#11#¥1232013Ī9Ԃ15ȕǰ2013Ī2014Ī4Ԃ30ȕǰͪ2014Ī5Ԃ16ȕǰͪ2014Ī6Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2014Ī8Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2014Ī9Ԃ10ȕǰͪ1,130Ԫ7#¥3714.35ƽ8#¥3546.05ƽ10#¥3879.41ƽ11#¥2062.83ƽ13202.64ƽ14,918,983.2Ԫͼ2011Ī2014Ī2010ĪЂ14%3%7%70.5Ԫ3%62%20Ϯ6Ϯ

2013Ī9Ԃ10ȕϮĿ18#21#22#24#25#¥1232013Ī9Ԃ15ȕǰ2013Ī2014Ī4Ԃ30ȕǰͪ2014Ī5Ԃ16ȕǰͪ2014Ī6Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2014Ī8Ԃ20ȕǰͪ2014Ī9Ԃ10ȕǰͪ1,130Ԫ18#¥3032.12ƽ21#¥3741.60ƽ22#¥3045.80ƽ24#¥3584.62ƽ25#¥2479.38ƽ15883.52ƽ17,948,377.6Ԫ2011Ī2014Ī2010ĪЂ14%3%7%70.5Ԫ3%62%20Ϯ6Ϯ

2013Ī11Ԃ18ȕ7#8#10#11#18#21#22#24#25#¥31331.472013Ī11Ԃ14ȕ2014Ī9Ԃ30ȕ320̬33,531,000Ԫ2013Ī9Ԃ10ȕ˹ǩ15%25%35%50%10%10%80%95%5%׷Ϊ2013Ī9Ԃ10ȕ˹ǩ2013Ī11Ԃ8ȕ˹ǩ

6#9#12#14#Ɍס¥17#20#23#26#27#28#29#2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕ2014Ī8Ԃ18ȕϮĿ7#8#10#11#¥ϮĿ18#21#22#24#25#¥2013Ī9Ԃ15ȕ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕ

6#9#12#14#Ɍס¥ϮĿ7#8#10#11#¥17#20#23#26#27#28#29#ϮĿ18#21#22#24#25#¥

Ҹ·31,122,583.68Ԫ20,886,154.22Ԫ

΂Ɍ170Ԫȏ

Ҹ·69,055,000Ԫ

2020Ī9Ԃ29ȕ׷2020052582,120,782.58Ԫ2020Ī10Ԃ29ȕש֯2020Ī11Ԃ3ȕ׷2020052582,055,488.72Ԫ6#9#12#14#17#20#23#28#29#Ɍס¥2013Ī6ԂЅϢ3,804,176.07Ԫ2020Ī11Ԃ11ȕש֯650,000Ԫ

Ҹ·8,105.21Ԫ6#9#12#14#¥16,337.28Ԫ24,442.49Ԫ

һɳ18,000,000Ԫș200414ûӐ׊֊ΞЧǩЎ˄ϮĿ7#8#10#11#¥ϮĿ18#21#22#24#25#¥ϮĿ6#9#12#14#ϮĿ17#20#23#26#27#28#29#20200525Ԭ82,055,488.72Ԫ6#9#12#14#ϮĿ17#20#23#26#27#28#29#2013Ī6Ԃ֐ȽȽӦ3,804,176.07ԪϮĿ7#8#10#11#¥Ԛ3%419,307.34ԪϮĿ18#21#22#24#25#¥Ԛ3%511,891.6ԪЧ3%3%

Ҹ·1һƚϮĿ61,700.4Ԫ202,280.13Ԫ1,506,479.38Ԫ2012Ī2һƚϮĿ7,625.52Ԫ13,231.69Ԫ3ɢˮ7,727.29Ԫ43.9×3.4×311,423.68Ԫ321159.07×5һƚϮĿ130,862.21Ԫ119,769.85Ԫ16,359.46Ԫ61-9©Ϯ604,130.38Ԫ7ש122,061.68Ԫ201,268.5Ԫ323,330.18Ԫ122,061.68Ԫ201,268.5Ԫ

΂Ɍ165,293.86Ԫ2ɌƷ549,450.75Ԫ3Ů803036,998.81Ԫ4.11#¥}80304,729.96Ԫ30804,729.96ԪӦ56#¥41,867.09Ԫ17#¥33,483.34Ԫ7#¥53,303.05Ԫ18#¥40,042.59Ԫ6̺ҕ8110,406.27Ԫ41,728.77Ԫ36,998.81Ԫ4,729.96Ԫ

ґϲҸ·50,000Ԫʕ274,950Ԫ346,463.05Ԫ3,532,760Ԫ170,000Ԫ4500Сƻ380,000ԪҸ·20,886,154.22Ԫӫɏʶ25,640,327.27Ԫ

Ӑ20,159,563.09Ԫ1.2015Ī2Ԃ14ȕҔ876,503Ԫ2.2015Ī10Ԃ17ȕҁ'΂֝2,897,820Ԫ3.2018Ī5Ԃ15ȕһƚһ141,851.99Ԫ4.2013Ī9Ԃ4,000Ԫ1,000ԪӨҔȏʦ֪ͨ2013Ī9Ԃ24ȕ΂Ɍ1,000ԪӦ2013Ī8Ԃ10ȕ΂Ɍ3,000Ԫ3,000Ԫ20,015,011.1Ԫ

Ҹ·76,777,922.05Ԫ

כɏ2,661,578.46Ԫ82,055,488.72Ԫ3,804,176.07Ԫ3%419,307.34Ԫ511,891.6Ԫ323,330.18Ԫ66,341.26Ԫ36,998.81Ԫ8,105.21Ԫ16,337.28Ԫ4,729.96Ԫ170Ԫ76,777,922.05Ԫ

2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց2019Ī12Ԃ13ȕ4,563,000Ԫ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕΞҬҩ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕ200414;Š2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց2019Ī8Ԃ19ȕ650,866.93Ԫ2,661,578.46Ԫ5.25%̬̬2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց8Ԃ25ȕ2,661,578.46Ԫ5%ԂԂ2015Ī8Ԃ16ȕց2015Ī12Ԃ15ȕ2,661,578.46Ԫ5%̬̬2015Ī12Ԃ17ȕց2015Ī12Ԃ31ȕ2,661,578.46Ԫ4.75%ԂԂ2016Ī1Ԃ1ȕց2019Ī8Ԃ1ȕ2,661,578.46Ԫ4.75%̬̬2019Ī8Ԃ2ȕց8Ԃ19ȕ2019Ī8Ԃ20ȕ2,661,578.46ԪΪLPR

18,000,000ԪĚϭӐ2018202015Ī8Ԃ14ȕư2018Ī5Ԃ

2,226,211.72Ԫ

7,934,774.04Ԫ79,439,500.51Ԫ69,055,000Ԫ7,934,774.04Ԫ

Ҳ˫5,000Ԫ

300,000Ԫ

כɏίԱ2020Ī11Ԃ25ȕ̖›2004142018202,661,578.46Ԫ650,866.93Ԫ2019Ī8Ԃ19ȕ2019Ī8Ԃ20ȕ֮2,661,578.46ԪΪ7,934,774.04ԪȽ̵154,615Ԫ131,422.75Ԫ23,192.25Ԫ12,304.85Ԫ12,234.82Ԫ70Ԫ650,000Ԫ552,500Ԫ97,500Ԫ

ש2020Ī11Ԃ2ȕ202127ñ֕67556,141.41ԪӦ

6#9#12#14#17#20#23#26#27#28#29#Ɍס¥Ƚ3,804,176.07Ԫ

2020Ī10Ԃ28ȕ20200525Ƚȫ

΂Ɍ2013Ī11Ԃ3ȕϲʩæӦ20mm

50%

31,122,583.68Ԫ19,720,978.56Ԫ֧11,401,605.12Ԫ֧

͵ңהȏʕ19,720,978.56Ԫ20,886,154.22Ԫ120,000Ԫ274,950Ԫ346,463.05Ԫ170,000Ԫ380,000ԪӨҔȏ3,532,760Ԫ41,898,545.83Ԫ

11,401,605.12Ԫ20,159,563.09Ԫ876,503Ԫ֐һ̗286,392ԪӨҔȏ590,111Ԫ2,897,820Ԫ141,851.99Ԫ4,000Ԫ֐1,000ԪӨҔȏ3,000Ԫ16,526,780.1ԪӨҔȏ27,928,385.22Ԫ

3,532,760Ԫҁ'΂֝876,503Ԫ֐ʣӠ}̗2,897,820Ԫҁ'΂֝

Ր201820

13%-2004147#8#10#11#¥18#21#22#24#25#¥3%3%ϵ˫3%931,198.94Ԫ419,307.34Ԫ511,891.6Ԫ3%ʴʂʵȏ

26#9#12#14#¥17#20#23#26#27#28#29#¥ϮĿ2013Ī6ԂզʵҢ˼Ƚȫ3,804,176.07ԪΪ3,804,176.07Ԫ

36#9#12#14#17#23#26#Ɍס¥ʩ2010Īה֎ǸרӃ201419Ӛ

43.9×3.4×20200525

5604,130.38ԪӦԬ

67#8#10#11#18#21#22#24#25#¥͢ǽ6#9#12#14#17#20#23#26#27#28#29#¥ϮĿһ7#8#10#11#18#21#22#24#25#¥͢ǽ

7323,330.18Ԫ

8556,141.41Ԫ202127ñ֕67549,450.75Ԫɳ

9171,830.64Ԫ

10110,406.27Ԫ2012Ī9Ԃ29ȕЭҩʩ2012Ī12Ԃ13ȕ120Ԫ/×

11335,864.4Ԫ50%167,932.2ԪӦ

12555,131Ԫ123#26#27#28#¥ɨ͢ǽ80ϮĿ23#26#27#28#¥26#9#12#14#17#23#¥֐yӦ3--20-60-45750Ԫ/b1,500Ԫ624,255.22ԪΪ˾76#9#12#14#¥ϮĿ֐ɢˮς300mm25,792.96ԪӦ

כɏ3,804,176.07Ԫ3%931,198.94Ԫ549,450.75Ԫ167,932.2Ԫ25,792.96Ԫ1,674,374.85Ԫ79,439,500.51Ԫ79,439,500.51Ԫ3,804,176.07Ԫ1,674,374.85Ԫ=81,569,301.73Ԫ

41,898,545.83Ԫ3,532,760ԪӐҬҩ˾41,898,545.83Ԫ

27,928,385.22Ԫ876,503Ԫ֐ʣӠ}̗2,897,820Ԫ141,851.99Ԫ30%50%50%70,926Ԫȏ4,000Ԫ֐3,000Ԫ3,000ԪΪґ27,999,311.22Ԫ

484,410.35Ԫ155,905.35Ԫ

כɏȏ͵ң41,898,545.83Ԫ27,999,311.22Ԫ=69,897,857.05Ԫ81,569,301.73Ԫ69,897,857.05Ԫ=11,671,444.68Ԫ

2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕΞҬҩ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕցʵ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց2019Ī8Ԃ19ȕ;ϢΪ2,236,621.64Ԫ2015Ī8Ԃ14ȕց2015Ī8Ԃ25ȕ;ϢΪ11,671,444.68Ԫ5.25%̬̬2015Ī8Ԃ26ȕց2015Ī10Ԃ23ȕ;ϢΪ11,671,444.68Ԫ5%̬̬2015Ī10Ԃ24ȕց2015Ī12Ԃ31ȕ;ϢΪ11,671,444.68Ԫ4.75%̬̬2016Ī1Ԃ1ȕց2019Ī8Ԃ1ȕ;ϢΪ11,671,444.68Ԫ4.75%ԂԂ2019Ī8Ԃ2ȕց8Ԃ19ȕ;ϢΪ11,671,444.68Ԫ4.75%̬̬2019Ī8Ԃ20ȕ11,671,444.68ԪΪ

7,934,774.04Ԫ69,897,857.05Ԫ69,055,000Ԫ842,857.05Ԫ7,091,916.99Ԫ7,934,774.04Ԫ842,857.05Ԫ

5,000Ԫ

כɏ˹ʶ200414ñ201820

һ201927ñ39

11,671,444.68Ԫ

Ƚ2,236,621.64Ԫ2019Ī8Ԃ19ȕ2019Ī8Ԃ20ȕ֮11,671,444.68ԪΪ

˄842,857.05Ԫ7,091,916.99Ԫ

Υ˟ˏǫdz

y

ȧ

һɳ154,615Ԫ61,846Ԫ92,769Ԫ12,304.85Ԫ199,191.41Ԫ150,521.42Ԫ48,669.99Ԫ64,724.21Ԫ134,467.2Ԫ3,254.33ԪӨҔ͋650,000Ԫ260,000Ԫ390,000Ԫ

ɳ

ɳ

ɳΡ

һ Ī Ԃ ʮ y ȕ

ʩ